Superior is not a big inland lake. It is a small ocean that happens to be fresh.
Three things catch people out, every single season:
- The water is cold enough to kill you in August. Air at 26 C means nothing when the water is at 9 C. Cold shock takes your breath in seconds and your hands in ten minutes.
- Fetch, not wind speed, decides what the water does. Fifteen knots behind the Sibley Peninsula is glass. The same fifteen knots at Marquette with 200 km of open lake upwind is a different lake entirely. That is exactly what the forecast on this site models.
- An offshore wind lies to you. The beach looks calm because the chop has not had room to build yet. Every kilometre out is a kilometre you have to fight back.
Wear the PFD. Tell somebody your plan. Pick a bail-out shore before you launch.